France has a radical idea for fixing its debt crisis

OPINION | by Luca Belgiorno-Nettis

October 27, 2026

I travelled to Paris last week for the city’s annual art extravaganza, Art Basel Paris at Le Grand Palais. Alongside the art, I saw shattered shop windows, mostly those of luxury fashion stores. As we flew out on Thursday, the organisers notified us that the fair would close the following day rather than remain open across the weekend as scheduled – more protest marches and disruption were expected.

Of course, street demonstrations usually do not appear out of the blue. There have been grievances for years about the decrepit state of the schools – now amplified by cost-of-living pressures.The grudges are not exclusive to Paris or indeed France. They have been replicated to a lesser extent in Milan, Madrid, and Lisbon among other cities.

France has borne the brunt. In this the French have form, and it’s not just in the French penchant for hitting the streets. French anarchists and the far-left movement associated with the 'Black Bloc' extremist grouping – are primarily associated with the property damage. But beyond the street violence lies a deeper concern: people are losing faith in the state’s ability to address their grievances.

The question is whether these protests will remain simply expressions of social discontent or develop into a broader challenge to established institutions. Underlying these demands is a difficult constraint: government debt. France’s public debt sits at 119 per cent of gross domestic product, Spain’s is just over 100 per cent, whilst Italy’s is at 140 per cent – the second highest in the eurozone, just behind Greece’s at 141 per cent. Even though people have legitimate grievances, there’s little room to move. Which politician is going to deliver the bitter pill?

Politics is all about trade-offs, and electoral politics does not handle bad news well. The reaction from the political class is predictable: the same old left versus right point scoring. Europe – like most of the Western world – is stuck in this adversarial rut.

We need to change. In this France has form, too. Earlier this year the French parliament took up the primary recommendations to legalise assisted dying following a national citizens’ assembly on “end of life”. Last month, France decided to undertake another citizens’ assembly this time on “public debt”, bringing together 150 randomly selected citizens to study how to introduce spending controls and potential tax/revenue trade-offs.

The Economic, Social and Environmental Council (CESE) is France’s constitutional advisory assembly, distinct from the National Assembly and Senate. It brings together representatives of organised civil society, including employers, trade unions and associations. Following reforms in 2021, it acquired a more prominent role in organising public participation and citizens’ deliberation. The public-debt assembly is the first national citizens’ assembly initiated independently by the CESE, rather than commissioned by the president or government. It has come immediately before France’s presidential election next year. The official question is: “What priorities should we establish, and what choices should we make today to regain control of our public finances, reduce the deficit and prepare for the future?”

That open remit matters. It does not prescribe spending cuts, tax increases or a debt-to-GDP target. Citizens can weigh expenditure restraint, taxation reform, economic growth measures and investment priorities. They can also identify what spending should be protected, even if that means reductions elsewhere. The CESE announced on October 23rd that recruitment had begun, principally using random telephone calls. The selection process has been designed to reflect French society across 6 demographic dimensions: gender, age, educational attainment, socioeconomic and occupational category, geographic region and urban/rural residential characteristics. The objective is to bring together a microcosm of French society.

A central issue is whether everyday citizens – given expert evidence and time to deliberate – can find common ground on difficult fiscal choices. The task is not simply to reduce debt, but to reconcile fiscal responsibility with competing social, economic and intergenerational priorities. CESE’s president, Claire Thoury, argues that citizens can develop informed recommendations when given the information, time and opportunities to deliberate — and that these choices should not be left exclusively to politicians, economists and financial administrators.

She’s not the only one to think so. In 2024, the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) issued a report concluding that citizens’ assemblies “enhance public trust in government and democratic institutions by giving citizens an effective role in public decision- making”. The study said that people are more likely to trust decisions influenced by ordinary citizens than decisions made exclusively by government.

There’s a sense of unease in Europe. Winter is on its doorstep, as is Ukraine. There’s economic hardship, but also a growing frustration with the political class. While most of the video clips of Paris over these past days have shown hooligans and shattered street frontages, there’s real change happening in the back rooms of the same city.

Read more here.

 

Scroll to top